Tuesday, April 28, 2009

(Erchin 16b) עד היכן תוכחה

The Rambam paskens like Rav that עד הכאה. The סמ"ג however paskens like R' Yochanan and asks on the Rambam why he didn't pasken like R' Yochanan.

The Kesef Mishna has an interesting answer. The Gemara says כתנאי and בן עזאי says עד כדי נזיפה like R' Yochanan. It was clear to the Rambam that we don't pasken like בן עזאי and therefore we can ignore R' Yochanan so he was left with a machlokes Rav and Shmuel and he paskened like Rav.

What does Rav mean when he says עד הכאה? The Rambam interprets it literally however, the בה"ל in Siman תר"ח quotes the Chinuch (רל"ט) that it is only עד שישהיה קרוב להכותו.

6 comments:

  1. The Jordan J23 Triple Black is one of the newest colorways of the Jordan J23, which is Jordan Brand’s newest training shoe.The Jordan J23 is a sleek and stylish trainer that has just debuted in a “Triple Black” color scheme. Built as a low-top, the shoe features a mesh upper with Jordan 11 "72-10" croc-embossed leather overlays on the mudguard, which extends onto the mid-foot strap. Completing the look is a thick, ridged midsole.Take a closer look at the additional images below and you can now find the Jordan J23 “Triple Black” arriving to select Jordan Brand retail stores, including shops like Titolo.
    The Air Jordan 4 Linen was Cheap Jordans a women’s exclusive release that debuted back in July 2006 and retailed for $115 USD.Dressed in a White, Boarder Blue and Light Sand color scheme. The colorway was so appealing that even guys were trying to squeeze their feet into women’s sizes. While having a dull-look, this Air Jordan 4 had contrasting hints of Blue on Jordan 11 Space Jam the Jumpman logos and inside the air bubble.Let us know if you guys were able to scoop these up back in 2006. If not, would you like to see Jordan Brand bring them back as a retro release?
    Kawhi Leonard debuted a special edition “Gold” Air Jordan 12 during a community meeting and greeting with Jordan 11 Spurs fans for the summer.This Air Jordan 12 features a full Metallic Gold-based upper with Black accents that appears to sit atop a translucent outsole.This Gold Air Jordan 12 Kawhi Leonard PE is in a size 14 and is highly unlikely to release anytime soon, similar to those Chris Paul PE’s we’ve seen him wear in Jordan 12 Las Vegas.Take a look at the full image below and let us know what you guys think in the comments section of this 1-of-1 Air Jordan 12.
    The Air Jordan 5 Raptors is a GS exclusive colorway of the Air Jordan 5 that has a similar color scheme as the Air Jordan 7 “Raptors” release.Draped Jordans For Sale in a mix of Black, Ember Glow and Fierce Purple. This Air Jordan 5 features a Black nubuck upper with Fierce Purple trim and Ember Glow contrasting accents atop an icy sole.Look for the Air Jordan 5 Retro GS “Raptors” to release tomorrow

    ReplyDelete

  2. شركة غسيل سجاد الكويت مصبغة غسيل سجاد الكويت
    فني كهربائي منازل الكويت كهربائي منازل في الكويت

    شركة تنظيف في الكويت شركة الكويت سيرفيس للتنظيف


    ReplyDelete