Friday, July 31, 2009

אמר ר' יונתן אפילו מאה - הוריות ג ע"ב

The Acharonim are bothered by 2 questions:
1. The Rambam (שופטים ט:ג) paskens that by the ב"ד הגדול we do not add dayanim, if so how can ר' נתן say 100 dayanim? How did they add 29 dayanim?
2. There is a din of אין ב"ד שקול so how can you have 100 dayanim?

The simple answer to the second question is that 100 is לאו דוקא, it is just a round number but it really was 99 or 101.

The מל"מ says maybe ר' נתן is talking about where they added שלא כדין however, he asks that ר' נתן learns his din out from a pasuk and it is very diificult to say that the pasuk is talking about where the ב"ד acted שלא כדין and he leaves it וצ"ע.

The Aruch Hashulchan answers that maybe we can be מחלק between הוראה and דין. In a case of דיני נפשות you can't have more then 71 dayanim and you can't have an even number. But maybe on איסור והיתר you can have more then 71 and it can be even.

The מהריץ חיות points out that the אנשי כנסת הגדולה had 120 members and it would seem that they were acting as the ב"ד הגדול.


Ari Shapiro said...

The Aruch Hashulchan is in חו"מ סימן י"ח

Unknown said...

In another life, Kobe Bryant could’ve been a soccer player. The Black Mamba grew up traveling nike free 5.0 with his father, an international basketball player, where Kobe would beg to go to his practices and watch Showtime era Lakers VHS tapes that his grandparents would ship to him. But what if those tapes never got there and Kobe’s love for the game of Nike Air Max Outlet soccer turned into something more? That’s the thought behind this latest Nike Kobe 11 Barcelona, a “Mambacurial” offering inspired by Kobe’s favorite club slated to release on September 8th for $200 USD.While Nike Basketball is offering up a ton of Mambacurial soccer inspirations from the Nike Factory Store OG colorway to a new What The Mambacurial, the Kobe 11 Barcelona is probably the most subdued of the bunch. The premium Flyknit upper utilizes a College Navy base with a contrasting University Red medial side in honor of FC Barcelona’s signature colors. A soccer Nike Air Max Outlet patch inspired heel matches the orange Swoosh branding – a hint at the squad’s alternate uniforms – while a classic gum bottom adds a lifestyle twist.What do you think of the upcoming Mambacurial Kobe 11 Barcelona? Be sure to check out official photos below and Nike Air Max 2016 stay tuned for more Kobe updates right here on Sneaker News.
Tinker Hatfield’s iconic 1987 creation, the Nike Air Max 1, stands as one of the most influential running sneakers of all time. Not only did it introduce the world to visible air, but a Nike Air Max bevy of initial colorways were so vibrant that it was hard to ignore the model upon initial release. Times have changed a bit for the Air Max 1, as it’s more of a lifestyle go-to these days has been updated by Flyknit, Lunarlon, and more nike basketball shoes of Nike’s latest technological endeavors to keep it up to speed.

Karen said...

This house flag is Officially Licensed by the NFL and is a high quality item for hanging from your porch or as an interior wall banner.Hang your Minnesota Vikings Double Sided House Flag with our banner pole or fly it with our 5' or 6' flagpoles and adjustable flag brackets.
stars and stripes flags,
football flags salecheap Philadelphia Eagles banners
Tampa Bay Buccaneers house divided flags, House Divided Flags,Sports Flags 3x5, Sports flags and banners,nfl House Divided Flags

Unknown said...

Come la scorsa stagione, il nuovo maglia di Roma combina una base rosso con accenti in una tonalità più scura del colore. Ma mentre il suo predecessore dispone di maniche scure, la camicia casa Roma 2016-17 è dotato di un modello di strisce in rosso scuro sulla parte anteriore, mentre il colore è utilizzato anche per il rivestimento intorno al collo.maglie calcio 2017,
maglie calcio poco prezzo,Maglia real madrid 2017 prezzo
maglia AC milan prezzo online

noor said...

شركة تنظيف في الكويت شركة تنظيف بالكويت
فني صحي فني صحي في الكويت
سباك الكويت سباك بالكويت

شركة تنظيف كنب الكويت شركة تنظيف كنبات الكويت
ادوات صحيه الكويت ادوات صحيه الكويت