Sunday, November 1, 2009

8a – does a reshus hayachid require hanacha in area of 4x4

As we learned in shiur, there is a machlokes if a reshus hayachid requires הנחה ע”ג מקום ד על ד or not. We learned the simple peshat of 8a that both Rebbi and Chachamim agree with Rav Chisda that indeed a reshus hayachid does not require it. This is the way the Rashba understands as well, though in doing so he takes us through all the sugyos from 4b until 5b showing that we need to check each one as many of them are not easy to understand in this light. This provides with a closer analysis of the cases and how to understand them and a chazara over those cases.

As we remember on 4a, the gemara asks – don’t we require both עקירה and הנחה from a makom 4x4? The first proof, that it is shitas Rabbi Akiva does not pose a problem since his example involves a hanacha in reshus harabim and thus we can say that this is not an issue within reshus hayachid. However, in the first suggestion of shitas Rebbi, the issue of the זיז would depend on how we understand the case of שדי נופו בתר עיקרו. According to Rashi, the tree is considered to be in reshus harabim, so again the hanacha comparison to our mishna is fine and does not require 4x4 in reshus hayachid. (See tosfos for alternative peshat)

However, as we continue, the Rashba says it would seem that the sugya on dapim 4-5 really does not agree with Rav Chisda, as we see from the טרסקל case. The gemara there explicitly says “התינח טרסקל ברשות היחיד” which clearly shows a need for a טרסקל even in reshus hayachid for an area of 4x4. Similarly, in the previous gemara, the second shitas Rebbis is one where the hanacha took place in a reshus hayachid, meaning that Rebbi is the one who holds you dont need 4x4 in a reshus hayachid but others disagree, meaning he is the one shita that holds this way. Also, the case of הכניס ידו לתוך חצר חבירו וקיבל מי גשמים, here too we have a case in reshus hayachid and the gemara asks where is the 4x4?

However, the Rashba deflects all these and explains that the entire sugya is really only asking in one directions – about the case of placing in the hand of the עני and not the other way around. And the focus of the sugya is never on reshus hayachid.

A few other interesting opinions about reshus hayachid are: the shita of the Rach (quoted in Ramban) that only above 10 does not require 4x4, so therefore Rav Chisda is not taking on the sugya on 4b-5a. Also, a difference is noted between a person – who is not the reshus itself and thus would require 4x4 (just that in the maskana the hand is good enough) as opposed to the reshus itself or objects in it like the amud.

10 comments:

Unknown said...

miami heat jersey
coach outlet canada
gucci shoes
tory burch outlet
cheap soccer jerseys
new orleans saints jerseys
kate spade outlet
christian louboutin uk
koby bryant shoes
true religion jeans
coach outlet
tory burch outlet
oakley sunglasses canada
michael kors outlet
hermes birkin
golden state warriors jerseys
the north face uk
washington redskins jerseys
air max 2015
air max 90
cheap nike shoes
atlanta falcons jersey
bottega veneta outlet
chanel outlet
nike outlet store
nike air max uk
juicy couture outlet
baltimore ravens jerseys
mbt shoes
mulberry outlet
michael kors uk
kansas city chiefs jerseys
real madrid jersey
arizona cardinals jerseys
beats headphones
ralph lauren uk
san francisco 49ers jerseys
burberry outlet
barcelona jersey
new york giants jerseys
hang0622

Unknown said...

15725meiqing
longchamp bags
kate spade outlet
chanel bags
christian louboutin shoes
football shoes
louis vuitton handbags
fitflops clearance
red timberland boots
polo ralph lauren
ray ban sunglasses
true religion sale
michael kors outlet stores
jordan 11 concord
jordan 11 low
hollister clothing store
oakley vault
christian louboutin sale
nike air max
louis vuitton outlet
pandora charms
louis vuitton handbags
hollister jeans
christian louboutin sale
louboutin
gucci shoes
toms promo code
louis vuitton outlet
gucci outlet
coach factory outlet
jrodan retro
kate spade
louis vuitton outlet
oakley sunglasses
abercrombie
coach outlet store online
hollister co
louis vuitton uk
ralph lauren sale
christian louboutin sale
burberry sale

Unknown said...

soccer jerseys,cheap soccer jerseys,cheap soccer jerseys for sale,soccer jersey,usa soccer jersey,football jerseys
lebron 12
tiffany and co
ralph lauren polo
oakley outlet online
coach outlet online
basketball shoes
snow boots outlet
air jordan 13 free shipping
tory burch outlet
ugg boots
chanel handbags
uggs outlet
michael kors usa
canada goose sale
replica watches
michael kors uk outlet
canada goose outlet
futbol baratas
michael kors uk outlet

chenlina said...

chenlina20160328
adidas running shoes
moncler coats
air jordan femme
michael kors outlet
michael kors uk
mont blanc
michael kors outlet
coach outlet
coach outlet online
replica rolex watches
cheap air jordans
coach outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
kobe shoes
louis vuitton outlet
ray ban sunglasses
ugg boots
coach outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet
cheap air jordans
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton handbags
ray bans
coach factory outlet online
cartier watches
hollister kids
coach outlet
coach outlet store online
hollister uk
coach outlet online
burberry handbags
adidas uk
michael kors outlet
ray ban sunglasses uk
coach factorty outlet
coach factory outlet
kate spade
ugg outlet online
as

Unknown said...

ugg uk
ugg sale
coach outlet
uggs canada
ray ban sunglasses uk
uggs outlet
ralph lauren uk
tory burch outlet stores
coach outlet
nike trainers
chanyuan2017.01.17

Unknown said...

michael kors
skechers shoes
michael kors handbags wholesale
rolex watches
bills jerseys
redskins jerseys
pandora charms
cowboys jerseys
instyler max
polo ralph lauren outlet

Unknown said...

christian louboutin uk
prada shoes
nba jerseys
christian louboutin
converse shoes
ray ban aviators
christian louboutin uk
oakley sunglasses wholesale
nike blazer shoes
red bottom shoes
20174.22wengdongdong

Obat Atasi Alergi Dingin said...

Thanks for sharing the information

Cara Mengobati Asam Lambung
Khasiat QnC Jelly Gamat
Obat Eksim Atopik
Pengobatan Herbal Penyakit Liver
Obat Paling Mujarab Diabetes Melitus
Obat Batu Empedu Alami

Cara Mengatasi Penyakit Asam Lambung said...

Thanks for sharing the information

Khasiat QnC Jelly Gamat
Obat Eksim Atopik
Pengobatan Herbal Penyakit Liver
Cara Mengobati Alergi Dingin
Obat Paling Mujarab untuk Diabetes
Obat Batu Empedu Alami
PENGOBATAN PENYAKIT AMANDEL

steve said...


افضل شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى الرياض شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى الرياض
شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى دبي شركة شحن عفش من السعودية الى دبي

معلم دهانات بالرياض

ارخص شركة نقل عفش بمكة
شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى الاردن شركة شحن عفش من السعودية الى الاردن