Friday, June 28, 2013

בתר מעיקרא או בתר תבר מנא אזלינן Bava Kama 17b

Rashi explains the din of Rabba where a person threw an item and then someone else broke it, that patur mean that the thrower is chayav and thus we see that Rabba holds בתר מעיקרא. The Ramban explains that the Rif understood Rabba differently, that Rabba actually holds בתר תבר מנא אזלינן and the meaning of patur is that therefore no one is chayav, since the thrower did not break it and the person who actually broke it broke a worthless object since it was about to be broken.

Rav Soloveitchik (רשימות שיעורים) explained this machlokes between Ramban and Rashi as follows:
According to the Ramban, each perpetrator should be looked at inidividually. For this reason, there is no chiyuv. The one who threw it would have been chayav if we held בתר מעיקרא and even had he died before the nezek happened, would have been chayav. But since we hold בתר תבר מנא, the only significant time is the breakage when the item was worthless. However, Rashi holds that we need to consider both times -- מעיקרא and תבר מנא, as both together caused the damage. The question of the sugya is who do we pin the chiyuv on (not who is responsible). Whichever we pick will create a chiyuv on the one individual and uproot the other's chiyuv, and creates an obligation on the entire act (thus having to pay even if we say בתר תבר מנא).

One other interesting note on this. The Ramban asked on Rashi from a case of murder: where a person throws a baby off a roof and someone else catches the baby on his sword (26b). In this case,the sugya says that the thrower is patur. What is the difference? Rav Soloveitchik points out the Ramban's question is very difficult. Unlike an inanimate object that we may consider worthless and broken as soon as it will break, this is not true in the halacha of people. As long as the baby is still alive it has a full status of being alive in the spheres of יבום and ערכין. Therefore, there is no possibility to consider בתר מעיקרא by murder.

22 comments:

Anonymous said...

shijun 5.20
gucci bags
hollister outlet
fitflops
christian louboutin outlet
abercrombie and fitch
louis vuitton
insanity workout
abercrombie store new york
michael kors purse
louis vuitton handbags
lululemon
jordan 11s
cheap oakley sunglasses
adidas wings
oakley sunglasses
abercrombie kids
true religion outlet
michael kors outlet
jordan 3
ray ban outlet
burberry handbags
coach factory online
coach factory outlet
marc jacobs outlet
louis vuitton uk
abercrombie
true religion sale
jordan shoes
michael kors outlet
louis vuitton
louis vuitton
mont blanc legend
gucci bags
tods sale
kobe bryant shoes for kids
abercrombie
copy watches
christian louboutin shoes
kate spade purses
michael kors bags

Unknown said...

jordan shoes
jordan retro 7
jordans shoes
jordans for sale
retro jordans
air jordan
jordan retro 13
jordan 11
jordan 13
jordan retro 7
lebron james shoes
nike hyperdunk 2015
kd 7
kobe 9
Nike Air Foamposite 1
Nike Basketball Shoes
lebron 12
jordans 11
kobe 9
kobe shoes
nike air max 95
nike air max 90
nike air max thea
nike air max 2016
nike air max 2015
nike outlet
nike air max 1
nike air max 2014
cheap nike air max
nike air max thea

Unknown said...

JIANBIN0707
air max 90
burberry outlet
true religion jeans
longchamp solde
true religion outlet
babyliss flat iron
beats by dr dre
coach factory outlet
camisetas futbol baratas
mlb jerseys
cartier sunglasses
tory burch shoes
louis vuitton handbags
true religion jeans
coach handbags outlet
ray-ban sunglasses
longchamp pas cher
tiffany jewelry
cheap ray ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses uk
adidas outlet
true religion outlet
tiffany jewellery
kobe bryants shoes
ghd hair straighteners
toms outlet
coach outlet online
rolex watches
lebron shoes
rolex watches
kobe bryant shoes
juicy couture tracksuit
fitflops clearance

Unknown said...

jianbin0707
air jordan shoes
michael kors outlet
swarovski jewelry
true religion outlet uk
longchamp
michael kors uk
cheap jordan shoes
michael kors outlet
nike air max
asics
michael kors uk
futbol baratas
true religion outlet
tory burch outlet
oakley sunglasses
nike air max 90
ferragamo outlet
true religion jeans sale
oakley sunglasses wholesale
kate spade handbags
louis vuitton pas cher
police sunglasses
tiffany jewelry
nfl jerseys
prada outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
louis vuitton sunglasses for women
ray ban sunglasses
replica watches
michael kors wallet
ray ban sunglasses
rolex watches
cheap oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet online
celine outlet online
louis vuitton pas cher
rolex watches for sale

xumeiqing said...

20161019meiqing
cheap uggs
michael kors outlet
burberry outlet
pandora jewelry outlet
coach outlet
nfl jerseys
kevin durant shoes
michael kors handbags outlet
cheap oakleys
ed hardy

Unknown said...

michael kors outlet
coach outlet
swarovski jewellery
coach outlet online
pandora jewellery
pandora outlet
polo ralph lauren
oakley sunglasses wholesale
coach outlet store online
rolex outlet
chanyuan2017.03.18

Unknown said...

michael kors outlet
cheap jordans
air jordan uk
discount oakley sunglasses
oakley sunglasses
yeezy boost
true religion
oakley sunglasses
michael kors uk
coach factory outlet
20170325huazhen

Unknown said...

lebron james shoes
coach outlet
true religion sale
levi's jeans
lebron 13
pandora jewelry
oakley sunglasses outlet
mont blanc pens
ferragamo shoes
fitflops uk
20174.22wengdongdong

caiyan said...

ed hardy
ralph lauren sale clearance
huston texans jerseys
fitflops sale clearance
adidas yeezy
beats by dre
fitflops
polo ralph lauren
adidas superstar
mulberry handbags
0504shizhong

Unknown said...

20170602 leilei3915
fred perry shirts
canada goose outlet
air jordan shoes
mulberry bags
prada outlet
fitflops clearance
kate spade outlet online store
canada goose jackets
kate spade outlet online
michael kors handbags

Foogle Packers and Movers said...

Top 15 Packers and Movers
Top 15 Packers and Movers in Thane
Top 15 Packers and Movers in Noida
Top 15 Packers and Movers in Kolkata
Top 15 Packers and Movers in Faridabad
Top 15 Packers and Movers in Ghaziabad
Top 15 Packers and Movers in Chandigarh
Top 15 Packers and Movers in Navi Mumbai

Walatra Gamat Emas Kapsul said...


Obat Migrain Tradisional
Penyebab Telat Haid dan Solusinya
Cara Menghilangkan Benjolan di Kelopak Mata
Cara Mengobati Kencing Tersendat
Obat Tradisional Telinga Berdengung
Cara Mengobati Prurigo
Obat Untuk Miss V Gatal dan Perih/Nyeri

Unknown said...

3、
cheap jordan shoes

cheap jordans

golden goose

ferragamo outlet

coach outlet online

reebok shoes

adidas outlet online

cheap jordan shoes

birkenstock outlet

mowang06-13

Unknown said...

WWW0919
ugg outlet
mulberry handbags
visvim shoes
kobe shoes
nike shoes
jack wolfskin
air jordan release dates
christian louboutin shoes
ray ban sunglasses
michael kors outlet

5689 said...

zzzzz2018..8.14
ugg boots
canada goose outlet
christian louboutin shoes
ralph lauren uk
coach outlet
pandora jewelry outlet
mlb jerseys
red bottom
ralph lauren outlet
manolo blahnik outlet

Unknown said...

herve leger dresses
russell wilson jersey
kobe shoes
vans shoes
lebron james jersey
jordans
jordan shoes
tom brady jersey
tory burch bags
mk purse
20188.17wengdongdong

John said...

ugg boots
kate spade outlet online
fitflop shoes
skechers outlet
louboutin outlet
coach outlet store online clearance
adidas store
moncler outlet online
louis vuitton outlet
city royals jerseys
20180821yuanyuan

Cara Mengobati Penyakit Gagal Ginjal said...


Very Nice Blog Updation Keep Updating !!

Obat Penyakit Insomnia Paling Ampuh Tanpa Efek Samping
Obat Herbal Paling Ampuh Untuk Mengobati Penyakit Hipotiroid
Cara Alami Untuk Mengobati Batuk Kronis
Cara Mengobati Penyakit Usus Buntu
Pengobatan Kelenjar Tiroid
Cara Mengobati Penyakit Ambeien Sampai Tuntas

Unknown said...

oakley sunglasses
balmain
toms outlet
beats headphones
air jordan
designer sunglasses
tods shoes
uggs outlet
christian louboutin
nike free
2018.9.13chenlixiang

نور الهدى said...

ارخص شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض

cara menggugurkan kandungan said...

I thank you for the information and articles you provided

Anonymous said...

When you are in lack money use cheap ecoatm to utilize your old electronic items by selling them. And get the sell amount without paying any fess all money will be yours.