Friday, December 21, 2007

הכא במאי עסקינן כשיכול להציל (Bava Metzia 22A)

There are 2 different מהלכים in the Rishonim how to explain what the Gemara means here.

1. The way it was explained in shiur which is Rashi's pshat is as follows. The ברייתא is difficult on רבא because the דיוק is that if he is not מתייאש the finder can't keep it which implies that יאוש שלא מדעת לא הוי יאוש. The Gemara answers that רבא has a different דיוק (and consequently a different pshat in the ברייתא). According to רבא the דיוק is that if he can save it (כשיכול להציל) then we don't say יאוש שלא מדעת הוי יאוש because he is not מתייאש. According to this it comes out when the ברייתא says מפני שנתיאשו הבעלים it means יאוש שלא מדעת. The ברייתא said it that way so that we could be מדייק that in a case of יכול להציל there is no יאוש שלא מדעת. As was explained in the shiur the הכא במאי עסקינן is going on the דיוק not the case.

2. Most of the other Rishonim reject Rashi's pshat (as it is very difficult in terms of the language of the Gemara) and explain as follows. הכא במאי עסקינן is changing the אוקימתא of the ברייתא. The answer for רבא is that the case of the ברייתא is a case where he can save it (כשיכול להציל) and therefore there is no דיוק fromמפני שנתיאשו הבעלים that is simply the דין because where he can save it we can't assume that he would be מתייאש. Therefore the ברייתא is not a question on רבא as there is no דיוק, it is simply telling you the דין that in a case where it is יכול להציל there is no יאוש שלא מדעת because we assume that he is not מתייאש.

4 comments:

Xiaozhengm 520 said...

oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet online sale
true religion shorts
designer handbags
ralph lauren outlet
coach outlet
jordan 8
kobe 9
ray ban sunglasses outlet
kevin durant shoes 8
nike air max
coach outlet online
toms shoes outlet online
adidas shoes
michael kors outlet
celine handbags
retro jordans
abercrombie & fitch
christian louboutin outlet
jordan 4 toro
ray ban sunglasses
ghd flat iron
ray bans
nike roshe run
gucci handbags
true religion
louboutin pas cher
celine outlet
christian louboutin shoes
toms outlet
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton
jordans
louis vuitton outlet
ray ban sunglasses
hollister clothing
michael kors
jordan retro
burberry outlet
nike blazers
2016.6.29haungqin

Unknown said...

louis vuitton neverfull
fitflop clearance
michael kors handbags
longchamp bag
nike roshe run
louis vuitton
nike tn pas cher
ugg outlet
burberry outlet
michael kors outlet
calvin klein underwear
michael kors factory outlet
ghd hair straighteners
hollister sale
michael kors outlet clearance
true religion jeans
nike mercurial
mulberry handbags
the north face jacket
michael kors outlet clearance
louis vuitton pas cher
michael kors handbags
mulberry handbags
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet
ray-ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses
cheap mlb jerseys
ralph lauren polo
cheap jordans
nike air max 90
uggs on sale
louis vuitton handbags
chrome hearts
louis vuitton outlet
chanyuan0913

dong dong23 said...

jordan outlet
adidas zx flux
coach outlet store online
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet online
ferragamo shoes
coach purses
michael kors outlet clearance
adidas nmd
manchester united jersey
20174.22wengdongdong

林磊 said...

20170602 leilei3915.
true religion outlet
michael kors outlet online store
cheap jordans
christian louboutin sale
kate spade handbags
polo outlet
nike shoes for men
ralph lauren shirts
ray ban sunglasses wholesale
cheap nba jersey