Monday, February 25, 2008

(שליחות יד גזלן ושואל שלא מדעת (בבא מציעא מ"א

What is the difference between שליחות יד and גזלן?

Tosafos ד"ה שנטלה writes that if the שומר takes it to steal it he is חייב because the גזילה itself is a חסרון. Why did Tosafos need to say that? Just say that he is a גזלן? We see from Tosafos that a שומר can never become a גזלן because he is an extension of the מפקיד and therefore the חיוב is always from שליחות יד.

Rashi asks what is the difference between שליחות יד and שואל שלא מדעת?

The Baal Hamaor and the Raavad hold that there is no difference, they are interconnected, if שליחות יד doesn't need חסרון then it is the same as a שואל שלא מדעת.

The Tur (סי' רצ"ב ועיי"ש גר"א) answers Rashi's question differently. The Tur says that שליחות יד requires that the use you are going to make of the object will cause a חסרון (based on the Gemara). When a person is שולח יד he is חייב as soon as he is מגביה however a שואל שלא מדעת is not חייב from when he picks it up but rather from when he actually uses it.

Take the following example. Reuven is watching Shimon's barrel. Reuven decides that he is going to use the barrel as a ladder. Using it as a ladder causes no חסרון and therefore he is not considered to be a שולח יד but rather a שואל שלא מדעת. He picks up the barrel and moves it to where he needs the ladder. Then Reuven gets a phone call and doesn't actually use it. In the meantime, an אונס happens and the barrel breaks. According to the Tur, since Reuven is only a שואל שלא מדעת, Reuven is פטור because the אונס occurred before he actually used the object.

The Ramban answers Rashi's question that the difference is that a שואל is defined as someone who gets all the הנאה, however, in a case where he is not getting all the הנאה but the original owner is still getting some of the benefit it cannot be called שאילה and therefore would fall under the category of שליחות יד. Here in our gemara, where he places he stick etc. on the animals back, the original owner is still benefiting from the שמירה and therefore it can't be called שאילה rather it is שליחות יד.


Anonymous said...

[size=72][color=red][url=]ENTER ON SOFTWARE PORTAL[/url][/color][/size]

[size=46][color=red][url=]DOWNLOAD SOFT![/url][/color][/size]


[size=46][color=red][url=]OEM SOFTWARE[/url][/color][/size]

[size=72][color=red][url=]DOWNLOAD SOFTWARE[/url][/color][/size]

[size=72][b]Download swassenLon soft programm on Mac[/b][/size]
[size=72][b]Online swassenLon soft programm on Mac OS x[/b][/size]
[size=72][b]Download swassenLon soft programms Windows[/b][/size]

Unknown said...

jordan retro 8
tods outlet store
tory burch outlet
michael kors outlet online
ralph lauren outlet
ghd hair straighteners
mulberry handbags
coach factory outlet online
true religion
polo ralph lauren
jordan 4 toro
ed hardy clothing
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton outlet
louboutin pas cher
coach outlet store online
coach factory outlet
christian louboutin shoes
kate spade handbags
michael kors outlet
coach factory outlet
jordan 11 columbia
beats by dr dre
ray ban sunglasses
true religion outlet
chanel outlet
michael kors bag
celine outlet
nike air max uk
ray ban eyeglasses
oakley eyeglasses
celine outlet
true religion jeans
ray ban glasses
michael kors
coach outlet
pandora charms

Unknown said...

Ever since appearing on our screens as Gabrielle in Desperate Housewives, Eva Longoria has had a special place in our hearts. So we take great pleasure in cheap oakley sunglasses featuring her in As Seen on today.Spotted leaving a Beverly Hills salon, the actress smiled for the cameras wearing 5076H sunglasses. A combination of hand polished acetate and enamel detailing, 5076H is very adaptable and would look equally suitable at the beach. Eva also wore an oversized knit, oakley sunglasses which is another piece that we’ll praise for its ability to dress an outfit up or down. But if we had to choose between the two, we’d Michael Kors Sunglasses choose 5076H, every time – we’re smitten with the wide-set temples and interlacing double CC logo, which still captures Chanel’s glamorous, luxurious look, but with a slightly ray ban outlet more contemporary vibe. We love.
Reese Witherspoon is a pro at pulling off the perfect day dress, and now she’s turning her skill to eyewear.She was spotted cheap ray ban sunglasses sale online outside her local church wearing Cary, a cat-eyed frame with fashion-forward appeal. And after getting a feel of Nicole Richie’s collection, we’re certain the line will serve as a standard go-to for the style aficionado.The range, lovingly named after Nicole’s daughter Harlow Winter-Kate, caters to modern women, those devoted to function as much as fashion. The variety of versatile sunglasses includes something for everyone, but no frame is better suited to Reese than Cary. Feline flicks work to flatter her face, cheap ray ban sunglasses while minimal details compliment her daytime ensemble. What an excellent choice, Reese.
Bryan Cranston's career has hit a new lease of life after his star turn in ray ban sunglasses the critically acclaimed TV drama Breaking Bad. And like all actors who are on-the-up Bryan's been finding himself on the charity benefit circuit raising money in the ray ban store

caiyan said...

lebron james shoes 2017
ghd hair straighteners
sanantonios purs jerseys
jimmy choo
tods shoes
cheap jerseys
gucci outlet
birkenstock sandals
oakley sunglasses outlet

Unknown said...

tory burch outlet online store
hermes belts
oakley sunglasses
fitflops sale clearance
true religion jeans
cheap ray ban sunglasses
kobe bryants shoes
air max 90
nike outlet online
michael kors outlet online

Unknown said...

20170602 leilei3915.
true religion outlet
michael kors outlet online store
cheap jordans
christian louboutin sale
kate spade handbags
polo outlet
nike shoes for men
ralph lauren shirts
ray ban sunglasses wholesale
cheap nba jersey

نور الهدى said...

شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة
شركة تنظيف منازل بالمدينة المنورة
شركات كشف تسربات المياه بالمدينة المنورة
ارخص شركة نقل عفش بالمدينة المنورة
شركة رش مبيدات بالمدينة المنورة
شركة كشف تسربات بالمدينة المنورة