Monday, March 3, 2008

(ר' עקיבא אומר כשעת התביעה (בבא מציעא מ"ג

What case is ר' עקיבא talking about? Is ר' עקיבא talking about the same case as ב"ה and ב"ש, namely שבח?

Tosafos says it can't be. Tosafos asks, if ר' עקיבא holds that שינוי קונה then he was קונה the שבח and he should keep it, if he holds that שינוי אינו קונה then he should pay for what grows even after the תביעה. Therefore Tosafos says that ר' עקיבא is talking about where the price of the object goes up. ר' עקיבא holds that even though כל הגזלנים משלמים כשעת הגזילה a שולח יד is different and pays the value of the object כשעת התביעה even if it goes down which is a tremendous chiddush.

The בעל המאור learns that ר' עקיבא is also going on the same case as ב"ה and ב"ש (namely שבח). He explains that ר' עקיבא holds that he doesn't get the קניני גזילה to be קונה the שבח until the time of the תביעה and therefore that is the time that is קובע. In other words, any שבח until the time of the תביעה belongs to the נגזל. This answers Tosafos's objection, ר' עקיבא holds שינוי קונה but only from the time of תביעה because that is when he gets the קניני גזילה.

The Rif says the opposite of the בעל המאור. The Rif says that any שבח that the גזלן takes from the animal is his until the תביעה, after the תביעה the שבח belongs to the נגזל.


Unknown said...

jordan outlet
adidas zx flux
coach outlet store online
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet online
ferragamo shoes
coach purses
michael kors outlet clearance
adidas nmd
manchester united jersey

Unknown said...

20170602 leilei3915
michael kors outlet clearance
oakley sunglasses
mont blanc outlet
prada outlet stores
michael kors outlet
ralph lauren outlet
ralph lauren outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet

Unknown said...

Are you looking for genuine valid YouTube likes? Leave behind your worries, we'll adequately help you to buy real youtube subscribers

Admin said...

Thank you for your support who has read our article. I'm very happy if you can share our article below

Cara Mengobati Sipilis
Obat untuk menghilangkan jerawat kelamin

Unknown said...

In case you are being assured round-the-clock Customer Service and lifetime replacement then don't rethink after you Buy facebook reviews from a provider. buy facebook page 5 star comments

نور الهدى said...

شركات غسيل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة

Sarah said...

Want to explore the mighty Arabian desert in the most fun and adventurous way? Book a desert safari deal with Evening Desert Safari. We offer the best services at the most affordable rates. Choose from one of our multiple deals and packages for desert safari and have the best experience of your life.

Desert Adventure said...

Desert safari deals top Tour Activities in the Dubai Desert. The Evening Desert Safari is the most exciting and favorite activity trip for the millions of travelers who visit Dubai every year. Quad bike safari is the ultimate entertainment for adventure lovers who want to experience extreme time on the desert sands.
Evening Desert safari deals and prices start from 45 AED. BBQ Dinner Buffet and more

Sarah said...

Desert Safari Dubai is an extraordinary method to investigate the opposite side of Dubai. A Stand alone outing where you can encounter a profound desert ride, Seated in an extravagance Land Cruiser and The Camel Ride past the halfway point. A total action to appreciate from the antiquated flavor to an advanced smell.

Driving school Blacktown said...

Outstanding article! I want people to know just how good this information is in your article. Your views are much like my own concerning this subject. I will visit daily your blog because I know. It may be very beneficial for me. premium desert safari

Desert safari dubai said...

What a well written and compassionate article. I found your ideas and wisdom encouraging and helpful.desert safari dubai deals

Christain said...


Geo tv dramas
Hum tv dramas
Ary Digital Dramas
dil zar zar

warren buffet said...

check out my websites

hum tv dramas
ary digital dramas
Geo tv dramas
Dil Zar Zar

charley said...

Check these websites
Iphone side
Hania Style

Zara Social said...

check out my articles


Dubai Desert safari said...

Enjoy beautiful sunrises and colorful sunsets like nowhere else on earth with this amazing tour to the sandy deserts of Dubai, United Arab Emirates. Dubai Travel Tourism is the Leading Tour Operator & Destination Management Company in Dubai.