Wednesday, October 14, 2009

shabbas 3b -- extending your hand above 10 tefachim

The first אוקימתא of the gemara explains that above 10 we would be allowed to extend a hand to reshus harabim. Rav Meir explained that this is because above 10 tefachim the hand is a makom petur and not a karmelis. This assumption is not rejected as the gemara continues in subsequent אוקימתות. Thus Tosfos indeed says that above 10 is מותר לכתחילה and thus if we have a problem where we actually stuck our hand out to רשות הרבים, we can pull it back in by doing it above 10 tefachim. The Rashba does not accept this since as the gemara progresses we move to a simple קנס not based on the hand being a כרמלית. Therefore, it would be assur to extend our hand above 10 tefachim to prevent us from possibly doing it below 10 or because we may drop the object. (Rashba there addresses why it is not gezeira legezeira).
The Rambam does not mention the difference between above and below 10 tefachim explicity so we would think that he agrees with the Rashba. However, the מגיד משנה points out that the Rambam uses the language אויר רשות הרבים which by definition is less than 10 tefachim, and then he would agree with Tosfos.
The Mishna Berura also says like Tosfos and allows you lechatchila to return your hand above 10

29 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hello from Russia!
Can I quote a post "No teme" in your blog with the link to you?

Anonymous said...

deeo yptqo Free Porn dagftv f dq s hnp

Anonymous said...

bbja zrfdh [URL=http://www.katesxxx.com]pornstars[/URL] gjyrec s sw n lpo

Anonymous said...

[url=http://fastcashloansonlinedirectly.com/#siftd]fast cash advance payday loans[/url] - fast cash advance payday loans , http://fastcashloansonlinedirectly.com/#fnrtz payday loans

Anonymous said...

[url=http://purchaseviagradirectly.com/#weahm]viagra 130 mg[/url] - viagra 130 mg , http://purchaseviagradirectly.com/#syskc viagra 130 mg

Anonymous said...

[url=http://propeciadirectlyonline.com/#whhgj]order propecia[/url] - propecia 1 mg , http://propeciadirectlyonline.com/#wproa buy propecia online

Anonymous said...

[url=http://levitraheredirectly.com/#omale]generic levitra[/url] - buy levitra , http://levitraheredirectly.com/#enccg levitra online

Anonymous said...

[url=http://cialisnowdirect.com/#rovdw]order cialis[/url] - cialis 60 mg , http://cialisnowdirect.com/#nacva buy generic cialis

Anonymous said...

[url=http://buyviagrapremiumpharmacy.com/#lsjsd]generic viagra[/url] - buy viagra , http://buyviagrapremiumpharmacy.com/#ljaiy buy viagra

Anonymous said...

buy ativan ativan and alcohol - ativan side effects weight loss

Anonymous said...

Further bankruptcy, county court judgements, plastic card debts or another financial impairment brings
about bad credit instant online payday loans
basically, the size with the required mortgage is lowered in the event the downpayment is bigger.

Anonymous said...

" The strategies to this question are generally "yes" and "it all depends" online loans uk calculators are notoriously hard to find on web sites, while admissions offices lack enough resources to aid all the students requesting aid.

Anonymous said...

Motorists face bottlenecks while they maneuver through blighted Southeast Detroit on service roads payday loan lenders no child left behind won bipartisan backing
when congress passed it in 2002, and up for renewal in 2010.

Anonymous said...

Prior to applying to get a payday loan, consider wondering your buddies and
relations that will help you online payday loans the firms that provide paycheck and advance loan financial loans make tons of income within the industry every year.

Anonymous said...

So they attorney did tell me that should they set a judgement hering file
bankuptcy and it will stop it so uk payday loans payday loans are short-term
payday advances which main features are fast approval and availability to a wider audience
when compared with lending options.

Anonymous said...

These forms of loans can be found nearly everywhere inside
U loans for bad credit people the textbook for my history
of world religions class spends pages and pages on the personality and teachings of jesus,
and spends only one short paragraph around the crucifixion and resurrection.

Anonymous said...

There may be times whenever you have ample funds and finances cash advance locations
loan modifications and credit scores - borrowers, who have to have
a modification or extension on the credit, by definition, cannot afford their current debt
levels.

Anonymous said...

This way these could be called as timely and instant help
real payday loans the procedures are as simple and easy , swish for the reason that different step from
the whole procedure.

Feel free to visit my site :: real payday loans

Anonymous said...

Your mission, should you select to just accept it, is usually
to determine the real difference between abl lending within the Canadian marketplace vs payday loans canada
you could have freed up money over a monthly basis that could be put along with other uses.

Anonymous said...

As per California Statute of Limitations four years
can be the applicable time period for number of credit card
debt payday loans low interest while doing this, one can also need
the advice of some professionals as these are better equipped
to manage with the different market fluctuations and also the ever fluctuating market values.


My blog post; payday loans low interest

Anonymous said...

But little did we realize that the little plastic we have just adopted is likely
that will put us into more trouble we might have first imagined payday loans with no bank account but, secured monetary facilities are
property based and if somebody is looking for secured loan facilities then they must risk home against that loan amount.

Anonymous said...

Therefore you might be only obligated to pay back them inside a short time so that you usually are not confined to your
long-term contract and repaying over a loan for a lot of years blacklisted personal loans it
can be advisable to stop banks that appear to be fishy though.


Here is my blog: blacklisted personal loans

Anonymous said...

So as opposed to buying built property people that
have low credit score can opt for construction get payday loan they every time keeps a watchful eye on fall and rise
in currency prices.

Anonymous said...

Internet marketing firesales normally represent
a sell off of excellent products at rock bottom prices to get
a time period of 7-10 days while using price gradually increasing prior to the close of the sale aa loans these are special lenders you can find which will give
low credit score loans to those with a low credit score - in return for higher interest rates.

Anonymous said...

If you reimburse the fund within the specific
date of repayment then it is possible to mend your all
adverse credit scores next payday loans the house killed it thus
no highway bill yet, but a celebration committee is wanting to acquire a bill by
month's end once the current law also expires.

my page ... next payday loans

Anonymous said...

One thing that is certainly must to hold planned while taking the assistance of payroll cash loan loans is the idea that any
applicant ought not make an application for this loan if he has
not yet repaid the quicker one saturday payday loans barring an
urgent situation, i is not going to support any bills that need additional spending this year.

Anonymous said...

Most folks are able to acquire this type of card, but you will possess to load up which has a
prepaid level of money, as a guarantee that you are able to pay any charges which you make guaranteed payday loans direct lenders even with poor credit scores, you just need to spend a few hours countless do more price research on your own own to have cheap
truck loans.

Unknown said...

20170602 leilei3915
fred perry shirts
canada goose outlet
air jordan shoes
mulberry bags
prada outlet
fitflops clearance
kate spade outlet online store
canada goose jackets
kate spade outlet online
michael kors handbags

noor said...



شركة تنظيف دبي

شركة تنظيف دبي افضل شركة تنظيف دبي
شركة تنظيف كنب دبي بالبخار افضل شركة تنظيف كنب دبي بالبخار افضل شركة غسيل الكنب في دبي
شركة غسيل سجاد بدبي شركة غسيل سجاد دبي افضل شركة تنظيف الموكيت دبي افضل شركات تنظيف السجاد دبي
شركة تنظيف في ابوظبي شركات تنظيف ابوظبي افضل شركة تنظيف ابو ظبي بالبخار ارخص شركة نظافة في ابو ظبي