Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Shabbas 49a - The Mesirus nefesh of Elisha Baal Kenafayim

The Rishonim all ask – this seems like it is a shaas hashemad, so shouldn’t one have to be moser nefesh for anything even not the big three – as the gemara states in Sanhedrin, even arakta demasana – the tying of the shoelace? Tosfos limits the ruling of arakta demasana to be something that is making you dress not like a Jew, while not wearing tefilin is different, since many Jews don’t wear tefilin all day so you won’t look like a goy. The Ramban and others formulate the difference as follows – tefillin is an aseh, so for bittul aseh we do not have to be moser nefesh, since שב ואל תעשה שאני. This leads to a different question, if he did not have to be moser nefesh, why did he take a chance in the first place and wear them? (Similar to the famous question on Mordechai why he risked his and Am Yisrael’s life not bowing to Haman).

This question leads to the BIG machlokes if one is allowed to give up their life optionally (not the big three and not shaas hashemad). The Rambam (יסודי התורה ה:ד) rules that one cannot do so as he writes: כל מי שנאמר בו יעבור ואל יהרג ונהרג ולא עבר הרי זה מתחייב בנפשו. The Lechem Mishneh asks from our case to this halacha and therefore rejects the ideas suggested above (aseh is different or based on how you look), However, he says that Elisha was able to take off his tefillin once he did the mitzva of wearing tefillin that day.

Other Rishonim use this case among others as proof that one may decide to give their lives. The Ran (based on the Ramban)  writes (on the Rif in our sugya) “שאע”פ שאינו מחויב ליהרג על קיומיה אפ”ה רשאי למסור נפשו עליה ומקבל שכר שכל מצוה שמסרו ישראל נפשם עליה בשעת הגזירה מוחזקת בידם ומקבלין עליה שכר הרבה ….”

For an interesting listen on this (related to Holocaust responsa: http://www.yutorah.org/lectures/lecture.cfm/728723/Rabbi_Aaron_Rakeffet-Rothkoff/2008-11-02_Responsa_06, about halfway through the shiur


Anonymous said...

If you¡¯ve clear on your accoutre, now comes the actually contrary part, the stalk for the dexter shoes. Should you north-easter the budget and splash exposed on a tandem of Christian Louboutin Pumps,

or should you be practical and stick to the more affordable consequential street? When you are shopping, try on as diverse pairs of Christian Louboutin Shoes as imaginable and rabbit on g rely with the most

comfortable. You¡¯ll be on your feet most of the date and there¡¯s nothing guaranteed to ruin that idyllic beam in your photos more than aching feet!

Matching the category of your put on one's sunday best clothes
If you¡¯ve chosen a standard nuptial bedeck, opt in compensation legendary shoes with a lowish heel. As your adorn is reaching the level, you won¡¯t investigate much of the shoes so it¡¯s powerful that

the bits that are seeable round out it. Aculeous toes are a persistent fair-haired boy and names to look out as categorize Christian Louboutin Sandals, Christian Louboutin Mary Janes and

Christian Louboutin Wedges A shorter, ballerina-length garb, on the other man, is unprejudiced crying revealed for a double of round-toes shoes. GChristian Louboutin Sandals have a tremendous selection.

Summer weddings
If you are planning a sanctification in the summer months, you whim be spoilt in regard to choice. You may unvaried be tempted by magnetic pearly or gold evening shoes or jewelled sandals. It¡¯s

importance checking faulty steep roadway stores as most of them have ranges that are irrational for the benefit of brides.

Winter weddings
A mingling during the winter months, on the other speedily, can bring its own problems. You don¡¯t want to wreck your fine shoes in the snow or rainfall and sandals are a no-no. An

luring selection is a duo of white Christian Louboutin Boots that on look in style and be common-sense too. Christian Louboutin has a traditional Victorian-style boot, while

Christian Louboutin ¡¯s satin knee-high boot is scattered with diamant.

Helter-skelter the framer:
www.uchristianlouboutin.com is online shoes shipping store, it sales a portion of way shoes, include[url=http://www.uchristianlouboutin.com/christian-louboutin-black-patent-leather-100-pigalle-pumps_p717.html] christian louboutin[/url] and[url=http://www.lcfshop.com] UGG[/url], you can note [url=http://www.uchristianlouboutin.com]christian louboutin sale[/url] and [url=http://www.lcfshop.com/sale-ugg-classic-tall-5815_c3]ugg sale[/url]

info here.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for good stuff

Anonymous said...

shamwow review
quicklawn reviews
Silver Sonic XL

Anonymous said...

shoes under
Perfect Fit
laundry ball reviews
Mister steamy

Anonymous said...

paid nursing jobs
best rn jobs
LPN Jobs

Anonymous said...

nurse jobs
RN Jobs
LPN Jobs

Anonymous said...

paid nursing jobs
CNA Jobs
Travel Nurse Jobs

Anonymous said...

top nursing jobs
online cna jobs
best travel nursing

Anonymous said...

While looking at the calendar on my desktop, I find out that it's less than 20 days away from the Christmas. Time is up to prepare a gift for my wife and family. Last year, the winter is so cold, I just bought her several [url=http://www.aniub.com]UGG boots[/url] to warm her feet. But now my beautiful and slim girlfriend deserved more than before! I decide to give her a big pleasantly surprised, She love the high heel shoes so much, may be this is my best choice,[url=http://www.clpumps.com]Christian Louboutin shoes[/url] is a popular brand in recent years, the red high heels can make a women looks much more sexy, the special design and its high-quality raw materials also attract my eyes. The price may be a little expensive, how ever, it's worth the value. The high-heel shoes are favorites of ladies because the shoes adorn their legs, especially for the ladies whose legs are short. Maybe people usually saw high-heel shoes in the nightclubs 30 years ago, but now high-heel shoes help ladies a lot on dress up, no matter what you dress, it looks beautiful when you are wearing a pair of high-heel shoes and will attract men's eyes. The red sole design of Christian Louboutin is very beautiful,especially the [url=http://www.clpumps.com/Discount%20Christian%20Louboutin-pumps_c15]Christian Louboutin Pumps[/url], it is also a sign of the Christian Louboutin for about 20 years, but the one I have booked at a online Christian Louboutin shop is red and black, it looks very graceful and special, I think my wife should like it very much when she see open the gift box. Well, you know, the Christmas holiday is a good time for dating, next year maybe I will buy diamond ring, but this year Christian Louboutin is the best Christmas gift. What about your gifts for your girlfriends or the other friends?

Unknown said...

polo ralph lauren
nike huarache
mcm outlet
nfl jerseys wholesale
hermes handbags
nike store
christian louboutin sale
michael kors outlet
nike air max
reebok shoes