Friday, July 5, 2013

bava kama - mishna 19b -- is meshune keren?

The Mishna on 19b begins a discussion about שן. It then discusses eating כסות או כלים and says the chiyuv is only 1/2 nezek, as Rashi explains - due to the fact that this is meshune. Does this automatically mean we have jumped to keren? Perhaps not. My Rebbe, Rav Lichtenstein שליט"א points out that the Rambam brings this halacha in perek 3 of hilchos nizkei mammon, which discusses nizkei shein. If it were really supposed to be keren, then it would have made sense for this to be elsewhere in the Rambam's discussion of halachos related to keren. 

This raises a possibility that meshune is a general din, not necessarily related to keren per se but any av. This would work well with the first mishna in the second perek as well which changes from regular regel to mevaetes (see tosfos there who says we did jump to keren but it is brought here since the din is parallel). There is one problem though with applying meshune to regel since they seem to be contradictory as the definition of regel is normative - היזיקו מצוי. Rav Lichtenstein suggested that the בעיטה that is meshune is in the context of a normal action of walking, as opposed to בעיטה we saw earlier that is pure keren -- in mishna 15b.

This solves another problem in that we we have been seeing two different chiyuvim of keren: כוונתו להזיק and משונה and they dont necessarily go together. So, we would now say that only כוונתו להזיק is keren. Of course we need to work this out with the issue if petur reshus harabim as well.


David R said...

Commenting on Tosfos on 22a דאפיך מיפך, Rav Soloveitchik (רשימות שיעורים) posits a different suggestion that there are 2 different types of keren -- one based on meshune and one based on כוונה להזיק. The one based on meshune may be more closely related to regel with the kula of 1/2 nezek.

oakleyses said...

uggs on sale, canada goose, oakley sunglasses outlet, mcm handbags, canada goose, soccer shoes, chi flat iron, gucci, babyliss pro, oakley sunglasses cheap, bottega veneta, asics gel, ferragamo shoes, ghd, soccer jerseys, cheap oakley sunglasses, ugg boots, ugg boots, valentino shoes, p90x3, canada goose outlet, moncler outlet, canada goose, canada goose, moncler, ugg, marc jacobs, ugg boots, tn pas cher, moncler, converse, ralph lauren, air max, oakley vault, herve leger, insanity, celine handbags, canada goose outlet, oakley, moncler, giuseppe zanotti, instyler ionic styler, ugg, louboutin, ray ban, cheap sunglasses, hollister, jimmy choo, vans

Unknown said...

canada goose jackets
canada goose outlet
juicy couture outlet
oakley sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
oakley sunglasses
true religion jeans
ralph lauren pas cher
lululemon pants

Unknown said...

michael kors outlet clearance
michael kors outlet clearance
ralph lauren polo
cheap jordans
air jordan 4
herve leger outlet
coach outlet
louis vuitton handbags
new balance shoes
mizuno running shoes

caiyan said...

ed hardy
ralph lauren sale clearance
huston texans jerseys
fitflops sale clearance
adidas yeezy
beats by dre
polo ralph lauren
adidas superstar
mulberry handbags

Unknown said...

20170602 leilei3915
fitflops sale clearance
cheap mlb jerseys
nike shoes
michael kors outlet online
true religion outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
michael kors
cheap oakley sunglasses
ralph lauren polo
ray ban sunglasses outlet

Unknown said...

michael kors outlet
ray ban sunglasses
reebok trainers
ugg outlet
balmain jeans
dolce and gabbana
longchamp solde
cheap jordans
coach outlet
pandora charms

5689 said...

ugg boots
canada goose outlet
christian louboutin shoes
ralph lauren uk
coach outlet
pandora jewelry outlet
mlb jerseys
red bottom
ralph lauren outlet
manolo blahnik outlet

John said...

ugg boots
kate spade outlet online
fitflop shoes
skechers outlet
louboutin outlet
coach outlet store online clearance
adidas store
moncler outlet online
louis vuitton outlet
city royals jerseys

Coqicoqi said...

Air Jordan 11
Pandora Outlet
Kyrie Irving Shoes
Jordan Retro 11
Air Jordan 9
Pandora Outlet
Red Bottom Shoes For Women
Kyrie 3 Shoes
Air Jordan Retro 9

Bilibili said...

Air Max 270
Jordan Retro 11
Red Bottom Shoes For Women
Pandora Jewelry
Kyrie Shoes
Jordan 11
Pandora Outlet
Pandora Jewelry
Yeezy boost 350 v2

biggboss13online said...

Aw, this was a very nice post. Taking the time and actual effort to produce a superb article… but what can I say… I procrastinate a whole lot and never manage to get anything done.
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai All Episodes

agacas said...

Love your website design, colour. I procrastinate a whole lot and never manage to get anything done.
kerala houseboat

nmoveruae said...

كنت أكثر من سعيد للكشف عن هذا الموقع الرائع. أريد أن أشكرك على وقتك بسبب هذه القراءة الرائعة !! لقد استمتعت بكل تأكيد بكل ما أوتيت من إشارة مرجعية لرؤية معلومات جديدة على مدونتك.
نقل اثاث بالفجيرة

Happy Mother's day said...

Happy Mother’s day, your number one source to get information about Mothers day. We’re dedicated to providing you the very best information about Mother’s Day. we are working day and night to provide authentic information about mothers day quotes,mothers day greetings.
Mom quotes

sialkotikuri said...

I hope it will be helpful for almost all peoples that are searching for this type of topic. I Think this website is best for such topic. good work and quality of articles ThanksWatch
Shakti Today Episode

sialkotikuri said...

Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it’s really informative. I’m going to watch out for brussels. I will be grateful if you continue this in future. Lots of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!
Namah Online

Nsmover said...

I was more than happy to uncover this great site. I need to to thank you for your time due to this fantastic read! If you want to search Best Furniture Packers Movers in Abu Dhabi then nsmover is best choice for you. I definitely enjoyed to give the answer of this and this article I really enjoy every bit of it and I have you bookmarked to see new information on your blog.
نقل اثاث في العين

adeel said...

Indian Drama Serial Tv Show Mujhse Shaadi Karoge Complete Hindi Show Latest Episodes in Hd

Mujhse Shaadi Karoge Latest Episode

adeel said...

Indian Drama Serial Tv Show Bepanah Pyar Latest Episodes in Hd

Bepanah pyar Latest Episode

Desi Serial said...

Welcome to DesiSerials Youtube Channel. We exhibit desi serial channels
broadcast online. Desi TV Serial that are loved by people around the world.

baali said...

Kasauti Zindagi Ki All Episodes

Watch latest and full episodes of your favourite StarPlus TV shows
online on hotstar, the one-stop destination for popular StarPlus serials

Kasauti Zindagi Ki All Episodes

biggboss15fullepisode said...

123Movierulz is a movie piracy site, which allows you to download the latest
Bollywood, Hollywood & Punjabi movies. If you are a movie lover you should know


video said...

MoviesFlix (2020): Download & Watch 480p 720p 300MB Hindi Dubbed Dual
Audio Movies, Best Alternatives & Similar sites, Website Features

imran said...

Kshow123 online, watch Kshow123 online English Subtitles, Kshow123 dub!
update about latest drama releases Kshow123 in Korean, Taiwanese, Hong Kong, ...

Kshow123 Online

Nancy murell said...

I have read your blog. This is really great. I like your work. I am also a blogger. Please read my blog and let me know your feedback on the same too.

cara menggugurkan kandungan dan mempercepat haid said...

I thank you for the information and articles you provided

Anonymous said...

WHY GO TO A DETECTIVE FOR THESE MATTERS?If you think that your partner is being unfaithful, go to professionals like those in our detective agency who are experts in marital problems. We will help you solve them. If what you are looking for is to solve your problem, with our private detectives in Madrid, you can do it. Our first consultation is free and without obligation.detective infidelidades

Anonymous said...

Watch and download Online free dramas in Fast Streaming and in HD Quality,
Kshow is a best and interesting dramas in English Subtitle.

K Show Live

U Know said...

Watch Your latest Pinoy Telesrye Replay shows Live, Pinoy Teleserye Today Episode Free Online, Pinoy Tv Shows watch online full HD pinoy shows Pinoy TV Replay

Bkmoversuae.Com بيت الخليج نقل الاثاث said...

hi we are the best
Home Movers in Sharjah

sanju said...

we are the best
explainer video agency in uk and usa

Vitamin B17 Benefits said...

Vitamin B17 is the “vitamin of next generation” when it comes to the natural, alternative and non-invasive cancer treatment methods.

cintadramatv3 said...

Watch Your Full Video Latest Episode Melayu Tv Dramas,
Download All myfilm4u Dramas HD Video melayutv3.

Cinta Drama

Asian HD said...

Very nice blog I have found today and really impressive content. Please keep updating on this topic.
KSHOW 123 Thank You So Much.