Tuesday, October 16, 2007

An alternative pshat in ההוא רעיא (Bava Metzia 5a)

The Gra (ח"מ סי' פ"ז ס"ק מ"ו and in much more detail in the שנות אליהו ליקוטים at the end of זרעים) offers a completely different pshat in the sugya of ההוא רעיא.

The Gra is bothered by a number of questions:
1. The Gemara says לסוף אמר להד"ם, what is the לשון of לסוף? What is this at the end of? This is the רועה claim in Beis Din.
2. Why doesn't the Gemara ask right away from the din of שבועת היסת? As soon as ר' זירא said that if we hold like ר' חייא the רועה would be חייב a שבועה the gemara should have asked even without ר חייא the רועה is חייב a שבועת היסת? Why does the Gemara wait until after we are מהפך the שבועה, it makes more sense earlier?
3. The Gemara asks at the end, ותיפוק ליה דהוי רועה? Rashi explains that this is a question on אביי, that even if he is not a גזלן he is still פסול because he is a רועה, so why did אביי ask from גזלן? However this is very difficult as גזלן is more חמור then רועה (it may be דאורייתא while רועה is for sure only דרבנן).

Based on this the Gra adopts the גירסא of the רי"ד that changes the placement of the word לסוף. Their גירסא is אמר להד"ם ולסוף אתו סהדי. The pshat in the gemara is as follows.

The רועה and the owner come into Beis Din. The owner says I gave you 5 sheep and the רועה says להד"ם. The רועה then takes a שבועת היסת like every כופר הכל. Then לסוף, after he has already taken a שבועת היסת , then 2 עדים come and say that we saw him give you 2 sheep. This answers question 1. The לשון of לסוף makes perfect sense, it means at the end after he already took a שבועת היסת the עדים came. ר' זירא then says, if we hold like ר' חייא the רועה would be חייב a שבועה דאורייתא and even though he took a שבועת היסת he would need to take the שבועה דאורייתא because it is more חמור. This answers question 2. Now we understand why we can't ask from שבועת היסת, he already took one. It is only after אביי says that he is a גזלן and therefore the owner swears that we can ask from שבועת היסת. The question is, since he is a גזלן the original שבועת היסת that the רועה took is null and void so let the owner swear and collect. To that the Gemara answers תקנתא לתקנתא. The Gemaras last question is not on אביי, but rather how could we have given the רועה the original שבועת היסת, he should have been פסול. This answers question 3.

The Gra points out that with this pshat we understand where the שו"ע got the din that is mentioned in סי' פ"ז סע' י"ד from. The שו"ע writes that if a person is כופר בכל and takes a שבועת היסת and then an עד א comes and is מחייב a שבועה דאורייתא he has to take the שבועה דאורייתא. The Rama then comments that if he takes a שבועה and it turns out that he was פסול the שבועה is null and void and he must pay. The באר הגולה and others cannot find a source in Shas for these. The Gra says that based on his pshat both of these dinim are explicit in our Gemara.

18 comments:

Da Shuai Guo said...

1Guo daye0928
cheap football shirts, http://www.cheapfootballshirt.org.uk/
ray ban uk, http://www.raybansunglass.co.uk/
los angeles lakers, http://www.lakersjerseys.us/
instyler, http://www.instylerionicstyler.com/
chanel handbags outlet, http://www.chanelhandbagsoutlet.eu.com/
new york knicks, http://www.newyorkknicksjerseys.com/
indianapolis colts jerseys, http://www.indianapoliscoltsjersey.us/
los angeles clippers jerseys, http://www.clippersjerseystore.com/
tiffany and co, http://www.tiffany-outlet.us.com/
san antonio spurs jerseys, http://www.sanantoniospursjersey.com/
arizona cardinals jerseys, http://www.arizonacardinalsjersey.us/
pandora outlet, http://www.pandorajewelryoutlet.us.com/
christian louboutin,louboutin,louboutin outlet,louboutin outlet italia,scarpe louboutin
tods shoes, http://www.todsshoes.us.com/
chiefs jersey, http://www.kansascitychiefs.us/
air jordan 4 free shipping, http://www.airjordan4.org/
ugg outlet store, http://www.uggoutletstore.eu.com/
coach outlet online, http://www.coachoutletcanada.com.co/
converse shoes, http://www.converseshoes.us.com/
san francisco 49ers jerseys, http://www.sanfrancisco49ersjerseys.us/
colts jerseys, http://www.indianapoliscoltsjersey.us/
links of london jewellery, http://www.linksoflondons.co.uk/
pandora, http://www.pandora.eu.com/
chicago bulls, http://www.chicagobullsjerseys.net/
cheap oakley sunglasses, http://www.oakleysunglasses-outlet.us.com/

方松腾 said...

soccer jerseys,cheap soccer jerseys,cheap soccer jerseys for sale,soccer jersey,usa soccer jersey,football jerseys
lebron 12
tiffany and co
ralph lauren polo
oakley outlet online
coach outlet online
basketball shoes
snow boots outlet
air jordan 13 free shipping
tory burch outlet
ugg boots
chanel handbags
uggs outlet
michael kors usa
canada goose sale
replica watches
michael kors uk outlet
canada goose outlet
futbol baratas
michael kors uk outlet

方松腾 said...

soccer jerseys,cheap soccer jerseys,cheap soccer jerseys for sale,soccer jersey,usa soccer jersey,football jerseys
lebron 12
tiffany and co
ralph lauren polo
oakley outlet online
coach outlet online
basketball shoes
snow boots outlet
air jordan 13 free shipping
tory burch outlet
ugg boots
chanel handbags
uggs outlet
michael kors usa
canada goose sale
replica watches
michael kors uk outlet
canada goose outlet
futbol baratas
michael kors uk outlet

柯云 said...

2016-01-19keyun
coach factory
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton handbags
ugg boots
coach outlet
pandora charms
cheap toms
louis vuitton outlet stores
ralph lauren outlet
toms shoes
uggs australia
uggs on sale
kobe 8
nike air huarache
cheap nfl jerseys
coach outlet online
coach factory outlet
canada goose outlet
ray ban outlet store
hollister kids
rolex watches
lebron james basketball shoes
ralph lauren home
uggs outlet
canada goose outlet online
christian louboutin shoes
michael kors bags
burberry sale
ray ban sunglasses
tods outlet online
tory burch shoes
uggs for women
louis vuitton outlet stores
michael kors outlet online
coach outlet store online
louis vuitton handbags
coach outlet online
ugg slippers
abercrombie & fitch
kate spade purses

Xiaozhengm 520 said...

coach outlet
louis vuitton outlet
gucci outlet
coach outlet
michael kors handbags
juicy couture
pandora jewelry
christian louboutin outlet
coach outlet
nike air huarache
kate spade handbags
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton outlet
fitflops sale clearance
michael kors outlet
nike sb
oakley vault
michael kors handbags
nike air max
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors handbags
air jordan pas cher
lebron james shoes 13
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
beats wireless headphones
lebron 12
louis vuitton bags
tory burch outlet
basketball shoes
jeremy scott shoes
oakley sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses
true religion outlet
mont blanc pens
louis vuitton handbags
kobe bryant shoes
cheap oakley sunglasses
nike sb shoes
jordan concords
2016.6.29haungqin

Gege Dai said...

JIANBIN0707
air max 90
burberry outlet
true religion jeans
longchamp solde
true religion outlet
babyliss flat iron
beats by dr dre
coach factory outlet
camisetas futbol baratas
mlb jerseys
cartier sunglasses
tory burch shoes
louis vuitton handbags
true religion jeans
coach handbags outlet
ray-ban sunglasses
longchamp pas cher
tiffany jewelry
cheap ray ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses uk
adidas outlet
true religion outlet
tiffany jewellery
kobe bryants shoes
ghd hair straighteners
toms outlet
coach outlet online
rolex watches
lebron shoes
rolex watches
kobe bryant shoes
juicy couture tracksuit
fitflops clearance

dong dong23 said...

jordan 4
adidas yeezy
coach outlet
louis vuitton handbags
polo ralph shirts
adidas yeezy
christian louboutin outlet
canada goose jackets
adidas shoes
gucci outlet
mont blanc pens
coach outlet
hollister clothing
ray-ban sunglasses
fitflops
dallas mavericks jerseys
cheap jordans
mbt shoes
ralph lauren
true religion jeans
jordan 8s
ugg outlet
coach outlet online
ralph lauren clearance
hermes bag
nba jerseys
jordan shoes
adidas originals shoes
michael kors outlet
cincinnati bengals jerseys
timberland boots
uggs australia
cheap rolex watches
ugg boots
uggs
canada goose coats
ralph lauren polo
louis vuitton outlet
ugg boots uk
uggs outlet
20168.25wengdongdong

Karen said...

Our Broncos Super Bowl 50 House Flag measures 28x40 inches, is constructed of 2-ply 100% polyester, and provides a top sleeve for hanging vertically from a wood flagpole or banner pole. The Broncos Super Bowl 50 House Flag is high quality screen printed with the logo as shown.
nfl american flags,
stars and stripes flags,
football flags saleHouston Texans stars and stripes flags

Karen said...

Il RasenBallsport Leipzig e.V. (abbreviato RB Leipzig – in italiano RB Lipsia – e anche noto impropriamente come Red Bull Leipzig), è una società calcistica tedesca con sede nella città di Lipsia, in Sassonia.maglie calcio 2017,
maglie calcio poco prezzo, nuove Maglia Atletico Madrid prezzo
Maglia Barcelona prezzo

xumeiqing said...

20161019meiqing
fitflops sale clearance
coach outlet
ray ban sunglasses
birkenstock sandals
oakley sunglasses
ysl outlet online
moncler outlet
oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet
coach outlet

chenmeinv0 said...

nfl jerseys
toms sale
clippers jerseys
ugg boots uk
cheap rolex watches
ugg boots sale
designer handbags wholesale
cheap mlb jerseys
fitflops sale clearance
nike roshe run shoes
201610.19chenjinyan

Hua Cai said...

prada handbags
coach outlet
coach outlet online
ralph lauren outlet
ray ban sunglasses
tory burch outlet
los angeles lakers
michael kors handbags outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
louis vuitton outlet
20161231caihuali

Unknown said...

michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors handbags wholesale
nike roshe run
michael kors handbags wholesale
cheap jordans
detroit lions jerseys
christian louboutin shoes

Obat kuat pria, Suplemen jamu kuat tahan lama said...

To add my insight into the broader need much information should I dig, one of his articles, vidio also one of his pictures as I can see on this page, please be able to provide feedback to me.
At the end of the comment word I say thank you.
alat bantu sex pria
obat kuat wanita
Obat kuat, alat bantu sex pria wanita 18+

raybanoutlet001 said...

green bay packers jerseys
armani exchange outlet
coach outlet
under armour outlet
ed hardy uk
kate spade outlet
coach handbags
nike blazer
ed hardy clothing
michael kors handbags

dong dong23 said...

lebron james shoes
coach outlet
true religion sale
levi's jeans
lebron 13
pandora jewelry
oakley sunglasses outlet
mont blanc pens
ferragamo shoes
fitflops uk
20174.22wengdongdong

John said...

adidas nmd runner
christian louboutin outlet
pandora charms sale clearance
giuseppe zanotti sale
heat jerseys
mlb jerseys
nfl jerseys
valentino
pandora charms outlet
cheap jordan shoes
20170722yuanyuan

chenlili said...

mlb jerseys
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet
canada goose clearance
ray ban sunglasses
ugg boots 70% off
montblanc pens
ralph lauren polo
ugg outlet
nike air max
20179.4chenjinyan