Tuesday, October 9, 2007

Does everyone hold from the סברא of ודאי רמאי? (Bava Metzia 2a-3a)

From the gemara on 3a it would seem that even the רבנן hold that you don't say יחלוקו if there is a ודאי רמאי because the Gemara asks on both ר' יוסי and the רבנן from חנוני על פנקסו that in that case there is a ודאי רמאי.

However, in fact, this is a מח' ראשונים. The last Rashi on 2a states that whenever you have a ודאי רמאי you say יהא מונח, the simple understanding of Rashi is that this is even according to the רבנן. A נפקא מינה is the case of זה אומר אני ארגתיה וזה אומר אני ארגתיה where Rashi says the din is יהא מונח because there is a ודאי רמאי. However, Tosafos (2b ד"ה אי תנא מציאה) as well as the Rosh in סימן א both disagree and say that even in the case of זה אומר אני ארגתיה וזה אומר אני ארגתיה where there is a ודאי רמאי, you say יחלוקו. They hold that the סברה of ודאי רמאי was only said for ר' יוסי. They bring a proof from the Gemara later (7a) from the case of שנים אדוקים בשטר where there is a ודאי רמאי and still the din is יחלוקו. Tosafos and the Rosh explain that according to the רבנן there is a different סברה, that the חלוקה יכולה להיות אמת. What this means is that we don't look at their claims whether they are lying or not but rather we look at the psak din, can the psak din be correct. In the case of זה אומר אני ארגתיה וזה אומר אני ארגתיה the answer is yes, it is possible that both of them own it and the correct psak is יחלוקו.

What do Tosafos and the Rosh do with the Gemara (3a) that we started with where the Gemara seems to assume the סברה of ודאי רמאי even according to the רבנן? The answer is that although the Gemara uses the language of ודאי רמאי that is לפי ר' יוסי, however according to the רבנן the question really is that by חנוני על פנקסו the psak din cannot be correct. Reuven owes his worker Levi $100 and tells him to collect from Shimon. Both Levi and Shimon now come to collect from Reuven. Reuven only owes $100 yet the psak din is to make him pay $200, $100 to Levi and $100 to Shimon. Even according to the רבנן that is a problem because the חלוקה cannot be אמת.

To sum up, Rashi holds that the סברא of ודאי רמאי is accepted by the רבנן as well and therefore in a case such as זה אומר אני ארגתיה וזה אומר אני ארגתיה the din is יהא מונח. Tosafos and the Rosh hold that the רבנן do not accept the סברא of ודאי רמאי, rather they have a different סברא, that the חלוקה יכולה להיות אמת. Therefore they hold that in the case of זה אומר אני ארגתיה וזה אומר אני ארגתיה the din would be יחלוקו בשבועה.

7 comments:

Unknown said...

15725meiqing
longchamp bags
kate spade outlet
chanel bags
christian louboutin shoes
football shoes
louis vuitton handbags
fitflops clearance
red timberland boots
polo ralph lauren
ray ban sunglasses
true religion sale
michael kors outlet stores
jordan 11 concord
jordan 11 low
hollister clothing store
oakley vault
christian louboutin sale
nike air max
louis vuitton outlet
pandora charms
louis vuitton handbags
hollister jeans
christian louboutin sale
louboutin
gucci shoes
toms promo code
louis vuitton outlet
gucci outlet
coach factory outlet
jrodan retro
kate spade
louis vuitton outlet
oakley sunglasses
abercrombie
coach outlet store online
hollister co
louis vuitton uk
ralph lauren sale
christian louboutin sale
burberry sale

Unknown said...

canada goose jackets
canada goose outlet
fitflops
juicy couture outlet
oakley sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
oakley sunglasses
true religion jeans
ralph lauren pas cher
lululemon pants
chanyuan2017.01.17

Unknown said...

michael kors outlet clearance
michael kors outlet clearance
ralph lauren polo
cheap jordans
air jordan 4
herve leger outlet
coach outlet
louis vuitton handbags
new balance shoes
mizuno running shoes
chanyuan2017.03.18

Unknown said...

nike shoes
fitflops
coach outlet
adidas yeezy
adidas outlet
rolex replica watches
cheap nfl jerseys wholesale
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet
longchamp outlet store
20170325huazhen

Unknown said...

polo ralph lauren
nike huarache
mcm outlet
nfl jerseys wholesale
hermes handbags
nike store
christian louboutin sale
michael kors outlet
nike air max
reebok shoes
20174.22wengdongdong

Unknown said...

tory burch outlet online store
hermes belts
oakley sunglasses
fitflops sale clearance
true religion jeans
cheap ray ban sunglasses
kobe bryants shoes
air max 90
nike outlet online
michael kors outlet online
20170525ck

Obat Benjolan di Langit2 Mulut said...

Thanks for the information, this is very useful. Allow me to share a health article here, which gods are beneficial to us. Thank you :)

Obat Tradisional Telinga Berdengung
Obat Penghancur Benjolan di Leher
Cara Mengobati Panu
Cara Menyembuhkan DBD
Cara Mengobati Luka Jahitan Bernanah
Pengobatan Untuk Kelenjar Air Liur Tersumbat